Buffer control system and method for a memory system having outstanding read and write request buffers

ABSTRACT

A memory controller and method for managing the issuance of read and write requests to a system memory is provided. The number of outstanding read requests and write requests issued to the system memory are separately monitored and further issuance of read and write requests to the system memory is separately controlled based on the number of outstanding read and write requests, respectively. For example, the issuance of read and write requests can be managed by halting and resuming the issuance of read and write requests to the system memory to maintain the number of outstanding read requests between first and second read thresholds and to maintain the number of outstanding write requests between first and second write thresholds, respectively.

CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATION(S)

This application is a continuation of pending U.S. patent application No. 11/650,218, filed Jan. 4, 2007, which application is a continuation of U.S. patent application No. 10/769,079, filed Jan. 30, 2004 and issued as U.S. Pat. No. 7,188,219 on Mar. 6, 2007. These applications and patent are incorporated herein by reference, in their entirety, for any purpose.

TECHNICAL FIELD

The present invention is related generally to memory controllers for controlling a memory system, and more particularly, related to memory controllers for managing a memory system having memory request buffers.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

Computer systems use memory devices, such as dynamic random access memory (“DRAM”) devices, to store data that are accessed by a processor. These memory devices are normally used as system memory in a computer system. In a typical computer system, the processor communicates with the system memory through a processor bus and a memory controller. The memory devices of the system memory, typically arranged in memory modules having multiple memory devices, are coupled through a memory bus to the memory controller. The processor issues a memory request, which includes a memory command, such as a read command, and an address designating the location from which data or instructions are to be read. The memory controller uses the command and address to generate appropriate command signals as well as row and column addresses, which are applied to the system memory through the memory bus. In response to the commands and addresses, data are transferred between the system memory and the processor. The memory controller is often part of a system controller, which also includes bus bridge circuitry for coupling the processor bus to an expansion bus, such as a PCI bus.

In memory systems, high data bandwidth is desirable. Generally, bandwidth limitations are not related to the memory controllers since the memory controllers sequence data to and from the system memory as fast as the memory devices allow. One approach that has been taken to increase bandwidth is to increase the speed of the memory data bus coupling the memory controller to the memory devices. Thus, the same amount of information can be moved over the memory data bus in less time. However, despite increasing memory data bus speeds, a corresponding increase in bandwidth does not result. One reason for the non-linear relationship between data bus speed and bandwidth is the hardware limitations within the memory devices themselves. That is, the memory controller has to schedule all memory commands to the memory devices such that the hardware limitations are honored. Although these hardware limitations can be reduced to some degree through the design of the memory device, a compromise must be made because reducing the hardware limitations typically adds cost, power, and/or size to the memory devices, all of which are undesirable alternatives. Thus, given these constraints, although it is easy for memory devices to move “well-behaved” traffic at ever increasing rates, for example, sequel traffic to the same page of a memory device, it is much more difficult for the memory devices to resolve “badly-behaved traffic,” such as bouncing between different pages or banks of the memory device. As a result, the increase in memory data bus bandwidth does not yield a corresponding increase in information bandwidth.

In addition to the limited bandwidth between processors and memory devices, the performance of computer systems is also limited by latency problems that increase the time required to read data from system memory devices. More specifically, when a memory device read command is coupled to a system memory device, such as a synchronous DRAM (“SDRAM”) device, the read data are output from the SDRAM device only after a delay of several clock periods. Therefore, although SDRAM devices can synchronously output burst data at a high data rate, the delay in initially providing the data can significantly slow the operating speed of a computer system using such SDRAM devices. Increasing the memory data bus speed can be used to help alleviate the latency issue. However, as with bandwidth, the increase in memory data bus speeds do not yield a linear reduction of latency, for essentially the same reasons previously discussed.

Although increasing memory data bus speed has, to some degree, been successful in increasing bandwidth and reducing latency, other issues are raised by this approach. For example, as the speed of the memory data bus increases, loading on the memory bus needs to be decreased in order to maintain signal integrity since traditionally, there has only been wire between the memory controller and the memory slots into which the memory modules are plugged. Several approaches have been taken to accommodate the increase in memory data bus speed. For example, reducing the number of memory slots, adding buffer circuits on a memory module in order to provide sufficient fanout of control signals to the memory devices on the memory module, and providing multiple memory device interfaces on the memory module since there are too few memory module connectors on a single memory device interface. The effectiveness of these conventional approaches are, however, limited. A reason why these techniques were used in the past is that it was cost-effective to do so. However, when only one memory module can be plugged in per interface, it becomes too costly to add a separate memory interface for each required memory slot. In other words, it pushes the system controllers package out of the commodity range and into the boutique range, thereby, greatly adding cost.

One recent approach that allows for increased memory data bus speed in a cost effective manner is the use of multiple memory devices coupled to the processor through a memory hub. In a memory hub architecture, or a hub-based memory sub-system, a system controller or memory controller is coupled over a high speed bi-directional or unidirectional memory controller/hub interface to several memory modules. Typically, the memory modules are coupled in a point-to-point or daisy chain architecture such that the memory modules are connected one to another in series. Thus, the memory controller is coupled to a first memory module, with the first memory module connected to a second memory module, and the second memory module coupled to a third memory module, and so on in a daisy chain fashion.

Each memory module includes a memory hub that is coupled to the memory controller/hub interface and a number of memory devices on the module, with the memory hubs efficiently routing memory requests and responses between the controller and the memory devices over the memory controller/hub interface. Computer systems employing this architecture can use a high-speed memory data bus since signal integrity can be maintained on the memory data bus. Moreover, this architecture also provides for easy expansion of the system memory without concern for degradation in signal quality as more memory modules are added, such as occurs in conventional memory bus architectures.

Although computer systems using memory hubs may provide superior performance, they may often fail to operate at optimum efficiency for a variety of reasons. One such reason is the issue of managing various buffers in the system memory, for example, memory request buffers and read data buffers included in the memory hubs. Typically, the various buffers are used by the individual memory hubs to handle memory requests in a more efficient manner, such as waiting until a sufficient number of outstanding write requests have been issued to the memory hub before servicing them, or for the purpose of efficiently routing read data sent back to a memory controller from upstream memory hubs after the read requests have been serviced. Monitoring the status of the various buffers of the memory system is desirable to prevent issues such as buffer overflow where continuing to issue memory requests may cause memory requests or read data to stall in the system memory. Additionally, managing the use of the various buffers in the memory system may require accommodating different buffer management goals. For example, it is desirable to allow for a large number of write requests to be issued to the system memory, while minimizing the number of outstanding read requests. Therefore, there is a need for a system and method for managing buffers of a system memory.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

FIG. 1 is a partial block diagram of a computer system in which embodiments of the present invention can be implemented.

FIG. 2 is a partial block diagram of a memory controller according to an embodiment of the present invention.

FIG. 3 is a partial block diagram of a memory controller according to an alternative embodiment of the present invention.

FIG. 4 is a partial block diagram of a computer system having a memory hub based system memory in which embodiments of the present invention can be implemented.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

FIG. 1 illustrates a computer system 100 according to an embodiment of the present invention. The computer system 100 includes a processor 102 for performing various computing functions, such as executing specific software to perform specific calculations or tasks. The processor 102 includes a processor bus 104 that normally includes an address bus, a control bus, and a data bus. The processor bus 104 is typically coupled to a cache memory 106, which, is typically static random access memory (“SRAM”) device. The processor bus 104 is further coupled to a system controller 108, which is also sometimes referred to as a bus bridge. The system controller 108 serves as a communications path to the processor 102 for a variety of other components. As shown in FIG. 1, the system controller 108 includes a graphics port that is typically coupled to a graphics controller 110, which is, in turn, coupled to a video terminal 112. The system controller 108 is also coupled to one or more input devices 114, such as a keyboard or a mouse, to allow an operator to interface with the computer system 100. Typically, the computer system 100 also includes one or more output devices 116, such as a printer, coupled to the processor 102 through the system controller 108. One or more data storage devices 118 are also typically coupled to the processor 102 through the system controller 108 to allow the processor 102 to store data or retrieve data from internal or external storage media (not shown). Examples of typical storage devices 118 include hard and floppy disks, tape cassettes, and compact disk read-only memories (CD-ROMs).

The system controller 108 includes a memory controller 124 that is coupled to the processor 102. The memory controller 124 is also coupled to a system memory 120 through a system memory bus 122 on which data, address and/or control signals are coupled away from or toward the memory controller 124. The system memory 120 includes a plurality of memory devices 130 coupled to the system memory bus 122, and further includes write buffers 132 and read data buffers 134 also coupled to the system memory bus 122. As with typical computer systems, the system memory 120 is used to store information, typically data or instructions, for use by the rest of the computer system 100, such as, the processor 102, the graphics controller 110, input or output devices 114, 116, and the like. However, the system memory 120 shown in FIG. 1 is an “intelligent” memory system that can monitor the types of memory requests issued by the memory controller 124, for example, read requests or write requests, as well as alter the order in which the memory requests are executed from the order in which the memory requests are issued by the memory controller 124. Additionally, the system memory 120 can also modify the flow of read data provided to the memory controller 124 from the order in which the read data is requested by the memory controller 124. The reordering of the memory requests as well as the return read data is made to improve utilization of the system memory bus 122. Handling of the memory requests and read data is facilitated by the use of the write buffer 132 and the read data buffer 134 included in the system memory 120. For example, the write buffer 132 and the read data buffer 134 are used to temporarily store write requests and read data, respectively, in the memory system 120 until a sufficient number of write requests are ready for servicing or until the appropriate time for transferring read data to the memory controller 124.

Further included in the system memory 120 is a memory request response circuit 140 for monitoring the servicing of memory requests issued by the memory request queue 204. In response to the servicing of a memory request, an appropriate response signal is generated by the memory request response circuit 140. For example, when a read request issued to the system memory 120 is serviced, and read data is ready to be provided to the memory controller 124, the memory request response circuit 140 generates a read response signal that includes the read data signals as well as a read status signal that identifies the read request corresponding to the read data. With respect to a write request that has been serviced by the system memory 120, the memory request response circuit 140 generates a write response signal that includes a write status signal indicating that the particular write request has been serviced by the system memory 120. As will be explained in more detail below, the response signals generated by the memory request response circuit are used by the memory controller 124 to monitor the number of outstanding memory requests issued to the system memory 120. Although in the embodiment described with respect to FIG. 1 the system memory 120 includes a memory request response circuit 140 to provide response signals to the memory controller 124, it will be appreciated that alternative approaches known in the art can be used to report the servicing of read and write requests to the memory controller 124. In the interest of brevity, such alternative approaches will not be discussed herein.

An example of a memory system that can be used for the system memory 120 is described in more detail in commonly assigned U.S. patent application No. 10/232,473, entitled METHOD AND SYSTEM FOR CONTROLLING MEMORY ACCESSES TO MEMORY MODULES HAVING A MEMORY HUB ARCHITECTURE and filed Aug. 29, 2002 and U.S. patent application No. 10/690,810. It will be appreciated by those ordinarily skilled in the art, however, that alternative system memories having buffers for storing memory requests and data can be substituted for the system memory 120 as well, and embodiments of the present invention can be utilized therewith without departing from the scope of the present invention.

FIG. 2 illustrates a portion memory controller 202 according to an embodiment of the present invention. The memory controller 202 can be substituted for the memory controller 124 shown in FIG. 1. The memory controller 202 includes a memory request queue 204 that receives from the processor 104 (FIG. 1) via the system controller 108 high level memory request signals, including command signals, address signals and, in the case of a memory write, write data signals. The memory request queue 204 also receives Request ID signals from a flow control unit 208 that uniquely identify each memory request. These Request IDs are combined with corresponding high level memory requests and stored in the memory request queue 204, preferably in the order they are received. The memory request signals stored in the request queue 204 include both read request signals and write request signals. The high level memory request signals and the Request ID signals will collectively be referred to as memory request signals. The memory controller 202 also includes a memory response queue 220 that receives read response signals and write response signals from the system memory 120. As previously discussed, the read response signals include read data signals as well as read status signals that identify the read request corresponding to the read data. The write response signals include write status signals that identify a write request that has been serviced by one of the memory modules. The response signals are generated by a memory request response circuit 140 (FIG. 1) included in the system memory 120 to allow the memory controller 202 to monitor the number of outstanding read and write requests that have been issued to the system memory 120.

The memory response queue 220 couples read status signals 222 and write status signals 224 to the flow control unit 208 so the flow control unit 208 can determine which read requests and which write requests have been serviced by the system memory 120. The flow control unit 208 makes this determination by comparing the status signals 222, 224 to the Request IDs generated and coupled to the memory request queue 204. As shown in FIG. 2, the flow control unit 208 includes read and write buffer control circuits 210, 212, which are used for independently monitoring the number of outstanding read and write requests issued to the system memory 120, respectively. As will be described in more detail below, the flow control unit 208 outputs flow control signals based on the number of outstanding read and write requests to the memory request queue 204 to control whether and when additional read or write requests should be issued to the system memory 120.

In one embodiment of the present invention, the read buffer control circuit 210 and the write buffer control circuit 212 include up/down counter circuits 214, 216 for monitoring outstanding read and write requests issued to the system memory 120. The counter circuit 214 is incremented by the flow control unit 208 in response to the issuance of a read request to the system memory 120, and is decremented in response to the receipt of a read status signal 222 for the corresponding read request. In this manner, the value of the counter circuit 214 is indicative of the number of outstanding read requests issued to the system memory 120. The counter circuit 216 is used to monitor the number of outstanding write requests in the same manner as previously described with respect to the counter circuit 214 for monitoring the outstanding read requests. Although using the counter circuits 214 and 216 has been described, it will be appreciated, however, that those ordinarily skilled in the art will obtain sufficient understanding from the description provided herein to implement embodiments of the present invention using circuits other than counter circuits 214, 216. Consequently, the scope of the present invention is not limited to the particular embodiment described with respect to FIG. 2.

In operation, the flow control unit 208 monitors the number of outstanding read and write requests through the use of the read and write buffer control circuits 210, 212, and the up/down counter circuits 214 and 216. In response to the number of outstanding memory requests, the flow control unit 208 outputs flow control signals to halt or resume further issuance of read or write requests to the system memory 120. In this manner, the flow control unit 208 can prevent overrunning the posted write buffers 132 and the read data buffers 134 of the memory system 120. Additionally, allowing for the number of outstanding read requests before halting further issuance of read requests to be different than the number of outstanding write requests before halting further issuance of write requests provides the flexibility to accommodate differences in buffer management between read and write requests. For example, it is generally the case that a large number of outstanding write requests issued to the system memory 120 is acceptable, and in some cases, preferable, whereas the number of outstanding read requests issued to the system memory 120 is preferably minimized.

Preferably, the read buffer control circuit 210 stores a programmable read request limit that defines the number of outstanding read requests that may be issued to the system memory 120 before the flow control unit 208 outputs a control signal to the memory request queue 204 halting further issuance of read requests. Similarly the write buffer control circuit 212 stores a programmable write request limit that defines the number of outstanding write requests that may be issued to the system memory 120 before the flow control unit 208 outputs a control signal to halt further issuance of write requests.

During the time issuance of the read or write requests are tolled, outstanding memory requests issued to the system memory 120 are allowed to be serviced, and consequently, clear room in the write buffer and the read data buffer of the system memory 120. With respect to read requests, when the number of outstanding read requests decreases below a programmable read resume limit stored by the read buffer control circuit 210, the flow control unit 208 outputs flow control signals to resume issuance of read requests to the system memory 120. Similarly, with respect to write requests, a programmable write resume limit stored by the write buffer control circuit 212 governs the number of write requests that can be outstanding before resuming the further issuance of write requests to the system memory 120.

Although the read and write request limits, and the read and write resume limit have been previously described as being programmable, it will be appreciated that the read and write request limits and the read and write resume limits can be a fixed value as well. As previously mentioned, programmable read and write buffer limits programmed into the read and write buffer control circuits 210, 212 allow for the buffer control to be tailored for the particular type of memory request, that is, either read requests or write requests, as well as to allow values to be selected that are indicative of the allowable read and write buffer depths of the system memory 120. It will be appreciated that in alternative embodiments, rather than have non-zero read and write resume limits, issuance of read or write requests can resume when the number of outstanding read or write requests decrease to zero.

As previously described with respect to FIG. 2, the flow control circuit 208 of the memory controller 202 included read and write buffer control circuits 210, 212 to monitor the number of outstanding read and write requests issued to the system memory 120. In an alternative embodiment of the present invention, shown in FIG. 3, the memory controller 302 includes a plurality of read buffer control circuits 310 a-d and a plurality of write buffer control circuits 312 a-d. Each of the read buffer control circuits 310 a-d has a programmable read request limit and a programmable read resume limit, and each of the write buffer control circuits has a programmable write request limit and a programmable write resume limit Each of the read buffer control circuits 310 a-d can be used to individually monitor a corresponding read data buffer in the system memory 120. Similarly, each of the write buffer control circuits 312 a-d can be used to individually monitor a corresponding write buffer in the system memory 120. In contrast, the memory controller 202 described with respect to FIG. 2 monitored the total number of outstanding read requests issued to the system memory 120 using the read buffer control circuit 210 and further monitored the total number of outstanding write requests issued to the system memory 120 using the write buffer control circuit 212.

As with the embodiment of the memory controller 202 described with reference to FIG. 2, the individual read and write request limits, and the individual read and write resume limits for the memory controller 302 can be fixed rather than programmable, or alternatively, some combination of fixed and programmable values. Moreover, the read and write buffer control circuits 310 a-d, 312 a-d can be implemented using counter circuits, as previously described with respect to the memory controller 202. Alternatively, those ordinarily skilled in the art will obtain sufficient understanding from the description provided herein to practice the invention using other well known or later developed designs and circuits. Consequently, the scope of the present invention should not be limited to any of the particular embodiments described herein, or to the use of any particular circuits described with respect to those embodiments.

FIG. 4 illustrates a computer system 400 having a memory hub architecture in which embodiments of the present invention can be utilized. The computer system 400 includes a processor 404 for performing various computing functions, such as executing specific software to perform specific calculations or tasks. The processor 404 includes a processor bus 406 that normally includes an address bus, a control bus, and a data bus. The processor bus 406 is typically coupled to cache memory 408, which, is typically static random access memory (“SRAM”). Finally, the processor bus 406 is coupled to a system controller 410, which is also sometimes referred to as a bus bridge.

The system controller 410 also serves as a communications path to the processor 404 for a variety of other components. More specifically, the system controller 410 includes a graphics port that is typically coupled to a graphics controller 412, which is, in turn, coupled to a video terminal 414. The system controller 410 is also coupled to one or more input devices 418, such as a keyboard or a mouse, to allow an operator to interface with the computer system 400. Typically, the computer system 400 also includes one or more output devices 420, such as a printer, coupled to the processor 404 through the system controller 410. One or more data storage devices 424 are also typically coupled to the processor 404 through the system controller 410 to allow the processor 404 to store data or retrieve data from internal or external storage media (not shown). Examples of typical storage devices 424 include hard and floppy disks, tape cassettes, and compact disk read-only memories (CD-ROMs).

The system controller 410 contains a memory hub controller 428 coupled to several memory modules 430 a-n through a bus system 454, 456. Each of the memory modules 430 a-n includes a memory hub 440 coupled to several memory devices 448 through command, address and data buses, collectively shown as bus 450. The memory hub 440 efficiently routes memory requests and responses between the controller 428 and the memory devices 448. Each of the memory hubs 440 includes write buffers and read data buffers, as previously described. Computer systems employing this architecture allow for the processor 404 to access one memory module 430 a-n while another memory module 430 a-n is responding to a prior memory request. For example, the processor 404 can output write data to one of the memory modules 430 a-n in the system while another memory module 430 a-n in the system is preparing to provide read data to the processor 404. Additionally, a memory hub architecture can also provide greatly increased memory capacity in computer systems.

The memory hub controller 428 includes circuits according to an embodiment of the present invention. That is, outstanding read and write requests are independently monitored, and in response to the number of outstanding read and write requests, the further issuance of read or write requests can be halted until the number of outstanding read or write requests decreases below a resume limit, at which time, issuance of the read or write requests to the memory may resume. In this manner, separate monitoring and control over the issuance of read requests and monitoring and control over the issuance of write requests to the system memory allows for independent buffer control.

From the foregoing it will be appreciated that, although specific embodiments of the invention have been described herein for purposes of illustration, various modifications may be made without deviating from the spirit and scope of the invention. Accordingly, the invention is not limited except as by the appended claims. 

1. A memory controller for use with a system memory, the memory controller comprising: a flow control unit comprising: a first buffer control circuit configured to determine a number of outstanding memory requests of a first kind issued to the system memory; and a second buffer control circuit configured to determine a number of outstanding memory requests of a second kind issued to the system memory, wherein the flow control unit is configured to provide a flow control signal to control further issuance of memory requests of the first and second kinds to the system memory based on the numbers of outstanding memory requests of the first and second kinds, respectively, including enabling issuance of additional memory requests of the first kind to the system memory when the number of outstanding memory requests of the first kind is within a range and halting issuance of additional memory requests of the first kind when the number of outstanding memory requests of the first kind is outside of the range.
 2. The memory controller of claim 1, wherein each of the first buffer control circuit and the second buffer control circuit comprises a counter.
 3. The memory controller of claim 1, wherein the outstanding memory requests of the first kind comprise read requests.
 4. The memory controller of claim 1, wherein the range is a first range and wherein the flow control unit is further configured to enable issuance of additional memory requests of the second kind to the system memory when the number of outstanding memory requests of the second kind is within a second range, and to halt issuance of additional memory requests of the second kind when the number of outstanding memory requests of the second kind is outside of the second range.
 5. The memory controller of claim 1, wherein the first buffer control circuit is included in a plurality of first buffer control circuits, each of the first buffer control circuits corresponding to a respective buffer of the system memory.
 6. The memory controller of claim 1, wherein the flow control unit is further configured to determine the number of outstanding memory requests of the first and second kinds based, at least in part, on a plurality of request ID signals and a plurality of response signals.
 7. The memory controller of claim 1, wherein the range is fixed.
 8. An apparatus, comprising: a controller configured to determine a number of outstanding memory requests of a first type issued to a memory and determine a number of outstanding memory requests of a second type issued to the memory, the controller further configured to control issuance of memory requests of the first type to the memory based, at least in part, on the number of outstanding memory requests of the first type and to control issuance of memory requests of the second type to the memory based, at least in part, on the number of outstanding memory requests of the second type.
 9. The apparatus of claim 8, wherein the controller is further configured to selectively provide a first flow control signal to control issuance of memory requests of the first type to the memory and to selectively provide a second flow control signal to control issuance of memory requests of the second type to the memory.
 10. The apparatus of claim 8, wherein the controller is further configured to maintain the number of outstanding memory requests of the first type above a first threshold and to maintain the number of outstanding memory requests of the second type above a second threshold.
 11. The apparatus of claim 10, wherein the first threshold is different than the second threshold.
 12. The apparatus of claim 10, wherein at least one of the first threshold or the second threshold is programmable.
 13. The apparatus of claim of claim 8, wherein the controller comprises: a first buffer control circuit configured to monitor the number of outstanding memory requests of the first type; and a second buffer control circuit configured to monitor the number of outstanding memory requests of the second type.
 14. An apparatus, comprising: a request queue configured to receive memory requests of a first type and memory requests of a second type, the request queue configured to selectively provide the memory requests of the first type according to a first flow control signal and to selectively provide the memory requests of the second type according to a second flow control signal; and a flow control unit configured to determine a number of outstanding memory requests of the first type and to determine a number of outstanding memory requests of the second type, the flow control unit further configured to provide the first flow control signal and the second flow control signal, the first flow control signal based, at least in part, on the number of outstanding memory requests of the first type and the second flow control signal based, at least in part, on the number of outstanding memory requests of the second type.
 15. The apparatus of claim 14, wherein the memory requests of a first type comprise read requests and the memory requests of a second type comprise write requests.
 16. The apparatus of claim 14, wherein the flow control unit is configured to determine a number of outstanding memory requests of the first type based, at least in part, on a plurality of request ID signals and a plurality of response signals.
 17. The apparatus of claim 14, wherein the flow control unit is configured to provide the first flow control signal to halt issuance of the memory requests of the first type responsive, at least in part, to the number of outstanding memory requests of the first type exceeding a first threshold and to provide the second flow control signal to halt issuance of the memory requests of the second type responsive, at least in part, to the number of outstanding memory requests of the second type exceeding a second threshold.
 18. The apparatus of claim 17, wherein the first and second thresholds are different.
 19. The apparatus of claim 14, wherein the flow control unit comprises: a first buffer control circuit configured to monitor the number of outstanding memory requests of a first type; and a second buffer control circuit configured to monitor the number of outstanding memory requests of a second kind.
 20. The apparatus of claim 14, wherein a flow control unit is configured to determine a number of outstanding memory requests of the first type by monitoring a servicing of at least one memory request. 